|
Post by TCM on Mar 12, 2010 18:14:33 GMT -5
I wish for the current discussion on homosexuality to remain here. The only interwoven thing between this and my thread on the cancelled prom is that itself. Nothing else should go there besides conversation on that specific incident. You can also comment on LGBT people as a whole here. Please be respectful of opinions regardless. No one take offense to see any argument of yours being criticized. You posted it here, you're responsible to handle others opinions as well. Two warnings, otherwise locking of this thread and punishment will follow, but that's up to the mods and admins on the severity. Even if it's still the spam board, even if you get no post count increase for it, you still act like you have intelligence.
EDIT: Since religion was the main basis of the argument, I'll allow that here as well. But those same rules apply to religion as well.
|
|
|
Post by RiderLeangle on Mar 12, 2010 19:00:53 GMT -5
Just out of curiousity.. Why did you decide a topic that you're intending to start a debate with in the spam forum? isn't Off Topic a more likely place if debate topics are allowed?
|
|
|
Post by Badalight on Mar 12, 2010 23:33:58 GMT -5
I always thought being "gay" wasn't much of a choice. If you're naturally attracted to someone, that's not a choice. Now actually forming a relationship with them might be "immorally wrong" but simply being attracted to someone can't be your fault.
So basically, all the people who are "naturally" born liking the same pretty much are going to hell no matter what? Right?
I don't see the logic behind that. I don't believe god would create a being and give them absolutely no chance at reaching his holy grounds.
If that makes any sense. I'm not well informed on either subject so I'm sure there could be something I have wrong/bad information on or I simply misinterpreted.
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 1:41:03 GMT -5
Well, the idea (I'm pretty sure) is that the gay people are supposed to suppress it and basically live a loveless life. No self-expression or true happiness for them. They should be with members of the opposite sex so they can hopefully be "fixed". That's what they get for being gay.
I've always seen it like this: I'm straight. I could not have sex with another man and REALLY, HONESTLY, 100% enjoy it. I cannot simply choose to enjoy it. It doesn't work that way.
So... how are gays different?
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 2:45:49 GMT -5
In response to robm: I figured there were studies. My point was that to say homosexuality comes from abuse is incorrect because there are gay people who have not been abused. Sorry for not being more clear. Why change one's nature? If God makes each and every one of us, I would think HE of all... beings(?) would know what he wants for us. I don't believe it's possible to change our nature anyway, though. All the hypnotism and desire to change doesn't change what's deep down. I believe there are some things that are just hard-wired in us and sexuality is one of them. I also don't consider the points about drug addicts to be relevant because that is not in our nature. That's simply an addiction. A disease. Homosexuality is neither of those. According to the American Psychological Association: As for NAMBLA, I, personally, would NOT say what they're doing is wrong. I believe that some people as young as 11 (probably younger, too) are ready for have sex. Not all of them, but some. On the other hand, though, some aren't ready until 16 or older. It depends on the person. It's their nature. Nature determines when we are ready to have sex, not our stupid laws. For proof of this, come to my town, go to my high school and count the pregnant students. NAMBLA, from what I've read, supports my opinion above and gay rights. So, unless I've terribly misunderstood NAMBLA's purpose, I believe I'd be fine with them speaking at my daughter's elementary school. However, I know where you're coming from. I know millions of people would fight for gay rights, then try to deny them when something like your scenario goes down. I'm not one of those people in this case, though.
|
|
robm
Nomura Masaki
Workin Hard!!!
Posts: 74
|
Post by robm on Mar 13, 2010 3:27:47 GMT -5
I got to ask, has anyone ever met a person who once lived a homosexual lifestyle in the past, and now is happily married? I have met a few. I have also met folks who lived their lives straight, and then "Came out" at 50 years old. If it was impossible to change, then did these folks change? Even though you can take a blood test, DNA, X-rays, of these individuals you cannot distinguish between them and currently practicing homosexuals. They at some point have said "I was born this way" yet they changed how, if change is impossible. Here is an article that states that a genetic cause cannot be directly establish. discovermagazine.com/2007/jun/born-gayMy favorite quote is: “Frankly, the biggest problem of the genetic possibilities is the evolutionary problem,” says Michael Bailey, the researcher who found that women get turned on by anything, who is now working with Sanders. “And I don’t think that Dean [Hamer] has taken that problem seriously enough.” Men who like men are obviously less likely to procreate. Even if social pressures through the ages led some gay men to have some children, the significantly lower rate of reproduction would eventually lead to the disappearance of the gene" I repeat here if, who says what is OK. If you don't want Bible thumpers telling you what to do, I can see that, but what happens when NAMBLA shows up at an elementary school, every argument you use to justify what you do, they will use. Will you say "What you do is wrong", and they will say "That's what you were told, you will deny me a right you fought for and got?". You cannot say "I can draw the line, you can't" or you will become the bigots you hate" Others feel the same way about homosexuality as any moral person (As I know you are) feels about bestiality or child molestation. Yet those who practice these deviant behaviors fell that what they do is "Normal" for them. Don't take this as me saying your a deviant, just you deride those who believe your behavior as wrong, and then say others are doing wrong how does that make you any different than the Bible thumpers that canceled the prom? As far as the Bible is concerned I can simply share what belief in Jesus has done for me. I was deep into alcohol, porn, cheating on my wife. Being an alcoholic, from a long line of alcoholics, I thought I could never change. One day I got into trouble for my drinking and was order to go to Alcoholics Anonymous (AA). I started working the program, and came in contact with a power greater than myself, and my life became much better. As I grew spiritually I grew closer to God, and Jesus. I am not, nor on this side of Heaven, ever going to be perfect. I am getting better, more moral, spiritual progress, not spiritual perfection. I changed, even though I was told my genes DOOMED me, and It's all God's fault. Now Oti you can equivocate about this contradiction or that hypocrite, and I will tell you what I found when Jesus found me. Tell me I'm wrong, and I will tell you, this is what has worked for me. I have found when someone has a disagreement with the Bible or religion, it's because they looked into the Bible and it disagreed with what they wanted to do, or some ill informed individual uses it as a club. The Bible is a book of hope, it starts out explaining the hopeless situation mankind finds itself in, defines a level of perfection our sin soaked minds could never obtain, and just when all hope is lost, Jesus comes and pays a price we could never pay. Only a God who cares so much for each of us that He would pay any price to save us, would allow His willing Son to step out of Heaven and save someone as wasted as I! A lot of us are brokenhearted because life doesn't seem to be fare, we lose love ones and we don't understand why. We have addictions, sins, so many things we feel helpless against, this is why Jesus was willing to die to give us hope, and the strength to change. Christianity, no matter how you've mistreated by "Christians" is not a series of do's and don'ts, it's an acknowledgment that we are not perfect and we need help, and a sign that Gos loves us and is willing to pay ANY price to save us. Some feel "I'm not good enough, I'll never make it", it's true. However, God knew this and has a plan. Some say "why doesn't God just save everyone?" because Heaven would become Hell to someone who thinks God is nothing more than a killjoy who limits them. I wouldn't want to spend eternity with someone who I don't like, who I think has either ignored me all my life, or caused all my difficulties. Love is a choice, I had to be created to be able to chose not to love for love to be real, or I would be a robot. If God forced me into Heaven against my will He would be every bad thing people say about Him. Before you get made at Christians, realize that some of us have made this choice out of love. Because a being that no need to create me did, that He had no obligation to save me, and yet did, and loved me when I couldn't even love myself.
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 3:46:47 GMT -5
Perhaps they did change. There's also the chance they never realized they were actually gay. Who's to say? You'd probably have to have a deep conversation with them to know. I understand there is no strong connection between homosexuality and genes (as far as I know). But, I don't believe everything natural about us is in our genes anyway. I'm sure that makes no sense. Sorry. I also repeat my stance: I wouldn't stop NAMBLA. They are simply striving for more rights: the right for gay boys to be able to agree with sex with older men. There's really no harm in it. That's where we have to draw the line, though. Harm. The right to have sex with three year olds. That's harmful. The right for gays to steal babies from straight couples because they can't have one of their own. That's harmful. There should be a fairly clear line with all these rights movements and whatnot. The problem is no one seems to have common sense anymore (not that I'm accusing you of this, I'm not). Wow, that flowed into this next paragraph perfectly. Beastiality, as far as I'm concerned, is fine. It's not even unnatural if you think about it. Several species will mate with other species (tigers and lions, etc.). As long as the animal isn't being harmed, I don't see a REAL problem with it (a real problem, not a moral complaint). As for child molesters, THAT is harmful to the child. I haven't thought much about it, but I suppose I believe they should be able to satisfy themselves to thoughts (and innocent pictures/videos, I guess). It really comes down to this: Is the child being harmed? No one is harmed when an old pervert masturbates in his bedroom while thinking about little Timmy next door. It's not a pretty sight (sorry for that, by the way ), but it's true. Here's the kicker about your last paragraph which was almost a preaching session: I believe you. I honestly believe with all of my heart that you were having a rough life and something bigger than yourself gave you the power and courage and work through it and change your life for the better. I cannot and will not deny you of that. That's wrong on so many levels. However, the fact you did it with an organized religion is unsettling.
|
|
FAMAS
Morikami Daisuke
Posts: 270
|
Post by FAMAS on Mar 13, 2010 12:38:27 GMT -5
Homosexuals I don't have a problem with. It's their business.
Religion, well I think that the Holy Bible, (Or as a friend of mine once called it, the Holy Babble) is a work of fiction. But I don't know about whether a god exists or not. Something can't come from nothing according to the laws of space, matter and time. So some people say that there must be a creator. But then somebody will ask, "Where did the god come from?"
Well maybe the god exists outside of space, matter and time? So the laws don't apply to the god? Hmm it annoys me so much that NOBODY actually knows...
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 13:17:29 GMT -5
Why does their "business" bother you? I mean, I don't really like the idea of two guys going at it, but I wouldn't say it bothers me.
I agree with you 100% on the religion stuff, though.
|
|
FAMAS
Morikami Daisuke
Posts: 270
|
Post by FAMAS on Mar 13, 2010 14:01:33 GMT -5
What? I was saying it doesn't bother me lol! I meant that it's their business what they do or don't do, so they can do what they like, because it's none of my business.
|
|
|
Post by Badalight on Mar 13, 2010 15:38:02 GMT -5
I read it wrong just like Oti did, the way it was typed made it seem like you said "I don't have a problem with homosexuals, but it's their buisness that I have a problem with"
Though I understand what you meant now.
|
|
FAMAS
Morikami Daisuke
Posts: 270
|
Post by FAMAS on Mar 13, 2010 16:15:09 GMT -5
haha yes I can see now why you'd think that.
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 17:16:29 GMT -5
OH! Sorry about that!
Damn. None of use can read.
|
|
robm
Nomura Masaki
Workin Hard!!!
Posts: 74
|
Post by robm on Mar 13, 2010 17:17:39 GMT -5
So FAMAS, where did anything come from? The Big Bang Theory has no explanation of what was happening 1 second before it happened. The Bible explains that God created time on the first day and thus is not effected by it. We see things from a temporal perspective, but there was no time before God created it and, there will be no time in Eternity. It's hard to explain because we have never experienced an existence without time. It kind of like when I was young, and no one could tell me how all those people got into my TV set. At the time I couldn't comprehend signals, cathode ray tubes, electricity, electronic circuitry, etc..., still can't tell you enough about it to make one from scratch, but I still watch Ninja Warrior on mine.
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 17:31:09 GMT -5
Nobody, not religious folks, Atheists or anyone in between, can know for sure where everything came from. Even if we all decide to throw logic out the window and believe the Bible, that still leaves us with a question: Where did God come from? "He has always been" is not an answer. There is an answer, though. Let's see if you know it.
|
|
robm
Nomura Masaki
Workin Hard!!!
Posts: 74
|
Post by robm on Mar 13, 2010 17:56:57 GMT -5
For you to say "I know for an absolute fact that NO where in the universe does God exists" is to say you have absolute knowledge, and thus you would have to be the God you say doesn't exist. If you don't except the evidence of God's existence that surrounds you, then it's easy to say "There is not evidence". What logic do you throw out, the irreducibility of cells, the incomplete fossil record (Of which Darwin said "If a complete, unbroken trial of fossils do not go all way back to the origin, then this theory will have to be discarded, and another considered), the lack of explanation what happened to make life self-replicating, why my heart aches when I see beauty(What part does art, song, or beauty play in evolution? Dogs do well without it.), or why I ask questions at all? Who put it in my heart to care? If the solution doesn't help me, why look for it?
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 18:07:22 GMT -5
True... except I didn't say that. I did not say there is no god, nor did I say I know for a fact there is no god.
That's because there IS no evidence. The Bible is NOT evidence. Why do people consider it so? Because it says it is? Is it that easy? Is it because it came from long ago?. If humans survive another 2,000 or so years and we look back on L. Ron Hubbard's science fiction novels that created Scientology, will we consider them the truth? Why not? How do you know? Just because his ideas sound crazy? Don't you think the idea of an invisible man in the sky with a zombie magician for a son sounded crazy at first too?
All in human nature. It is human nature to look up for things bigger than ourselves and wonder where we came from, why we're here and what the deal is with these thumbs.
|
|
robm
Nomura Masaki
Workin Hard!!!
Posts: 74
|
Post by robm on Mar 13, 2010 19:37:25 GMT -5
'What logic do you throw out, the irreducibility of cells, the incomplete fossil record (Of which Darwin said "If a complete, unbroken trial of fossils do not go all way back to the origin, then this theory will have to be discarded, and another considered)"
This is not from the Bible, it is from science. Plenty of science remains unanswered BY science, so what you have is a theory, and faith that that theory is correct. Science of this nature has it's own dogma about it.
|
|
|
Post by Oti on Mar 13, 2010 21:50:24 GMT -5
True, but at least science continues to learn and it admits when it's wrong. Does the the Bible ever change? Does it ever admit to its contradictions and straight-up LIES? No, it does not. If anything is questioned, the churches simply tell their followers to ignore the questions because those asking them are "sinners". The church conveniently answers everything.
Also, science does not claim to be "perfect" or all-knowing. It does not claim to answer everything. It is common knowledge that all our scientific discoveries are but a single drop in an ocean of knowledge. The Bible claims it is everything.
I also feel compelled to point this out: Just because I'm saying the Bible is BS doesn't mean I think science is perfect, nor do I believe the Big Bang Theory. I honestly believe there is something bigger than all of us out there. A "god", essentially. But because I don't believe in YOUR god and YOUR Bible, I don't know what I'm talking about?
It's illogical conclusions like that that show what organized religions REALLY are: CULTS.
|
|
FAMAS
Morikami Daisuke
Posts: 270
|
Post by FAMAS on Mar 15, 2010 9:55:19 GMT -5
So FAMAS, where did anything come from? The Big Bang Theory has no explanation of what was happening 1 second before it happened. The Bible explains that God created time on the first day and thus is not effected by it. We see things from a temporal perspective, but there was no time before God created it and, there will be no time in Eternity. It's hard to explain because we have never experienced an existence without time. It kind of like when I was young, and no one could tell me how all those people got into my TV set. At the time I couldn't comprehend signals, cathode ray tubes, electricity, electronic circuitry, etc..., still can't tell you enough about it to make one from scratch, but I still watch Ninja Warrior on mine. Okay, I have a question. What makes Christianity's God more believable than Islam's Allah? Didn't he make time on the first day too? How do I know which religion is telling the truth?
|
|